Moral Development and Ethical Decision Making in Tax Compliance: Evidence from Accountants in Malaysia

A. D. Tejwant Singh, Veerinderjeet Singh (1999) Moral Development and Ethical Decision Making in Tax Compliance: Evidence from Accountants in Malaysia. PhD thesis, Universiti Pertanian Malaysia.

[img] PDF
1221Kb

Abstract

The objective of this study is to identify and empirically investigate some factors that may influence ethical decision-making by accountants in a tax compliance conflict situation. This study attempts to determine whether moral development influences tax compliance decision-making and behaviour in the context of Kohlbergs' cognitive moral development theory. It also specifically considers the individual and joint effects of a number of variables such as moral development, individual differences (type of firm and legitimacy) and size of tax deduction (contextual variable). An empirical model was developed from a review of the literature on ethical decision-making in business and marketing. The model considers the individual and joint influences of the variables stated above. Accountants' ethical decision-making was operationalised in terms of the response to three tax compliance conflict situations. Eleven null hypotheses were developed for testing. A representative sample of one hundred and eighty accountants from Certified Public Accounting (CPA) firms were selected as subjects for the mail survey. The data was analysed using multiple regression as well as probit and logit estimation techniques. Of the eleven null hypotheses, one was rejected whereas there were mixed results for five others. The results for these five hypotheses were significant (at the 1% level) in two out of the three conflict situations. The contextual variable was a significant explanatory variable. Moral development was only significant when it interacted with either the contextual variable, the type of firm or legitimacy in different conflict situations. Although moral development was not a significant explanatory variable, it did perform well as an interaction variable. As such, the results lend support to the interactionist model used in the study. The type of firm variable performed well with regard to one of the conflict situations, thus indicating that there are differences in the way respondents from different firms make decisions. As for socio-economic variables, the most significant variable was membership of a professional body. The overall conclusion that emerges from this study is that moral development is important as an interaction variable when it interacts with other variables such as context, type of firm or legitimacy. Various recommendations are made following the findings of the study. These involve educational interventions, ethics intervention, the role of professional bodies and improving legitimacy. Future research is also suggested in respect of further testing of the model used in the study.

Item Type:Thesis (PhD)
Subject:Moral development
Subject:Ethics
Chairman Supervisor:Associate Professor Dr. K. Kuperan Viswanathan
Call Number:FEP 1999 10
Faculty or Institute:Faculty of Economics and Management
ID Code:8250
Deposited By: Nurul Hayatie Hashim
Deposited On:08 Nov 2010 07:11
Last Modified:08 Nov 2010 07:20

Repository Staff Only: item control page

Document Download Statistics

This item has been downloaded for since 08 Nov 2010 07:11.

View statistics for "Moral Development and Ethical Decision Making in Tax Compliance: Evidence from Accountants in Malaysia"


Universiti Putra Malaysia Institutional Repository

Universiti Putra Malaysia Institutional Repository is an on-line digital archive that serves as a central collection and storage of scientific information and research at the Universiti Putra Malaysia.

Currently, the collections deposited in the IR consists of Master and PhD theses, Master and PhD Project Report, Journal Articles, Journal Bulletins, Conference Papers, UPM News, Newspaper Cuttings, Patents and Inaugural Lectures.

As the policy of the university does not permit users to view thesis in full text, access is only given to the first 24 pages only.